Haiti: employing the partnership paradigm
Thursday, January 05, 2012
While the wider humanitarian response to the 2010 earthquake in Haiti garnered criticism, pockets of genuine success have emerged from the rubble. Two years on, one of the most important lessons learned has been the value of engaging local partners on the ground to help facilitate an effective response.
In the wake of the extraordinary devastation wrought by the January 2010 earthquake in Haiti, the international community descended on the island nation with an unprecedented relief and recovery effort. At one point Haiti had more nongovernmental organisations on its soil than did any other country, save the 100-times more populous India.
The aid and development scene in the western hemisphere’s poorest country has been a difficult one for some time. The earthquake’s aftermath further exposed longstanding structural and systemic problems that made the humanitarian response all the more challenging.
And it did not take long for scathing criticism to emerge about the lack of relevance and effectiveness of the overall humanitarian response.
A briefing paper issued one year after the earthquake by a collection of aid organisations, including ACT Alliance member Christian Aid, criticised the overall humanitarian effort for prioritising the needs of donors, governments and businesses at the expense of Haitian civil society and community-based organisations. In the same vein, an Oxfam report declared that “Too many donors from rich countries have pursued their own aid priorities” at the expense of those in need.
Recovery from the bottom up
In contrast to this top-down approach, ACT Alliance – one of the largest blocs of humanitarian support in the country – has placed a strong emphasis on working with longstanding local partners, with some relationships going all the way back to the 1950s.
These Haitian partner organisations already had the trust of local communities before the quake struck, and so were able to help facilitate the ACT emergency response in its initial phases. In the quake’s chaotic and dangerous aftermath, for example, many aid agencies felt the need to rely on military escorts to distribute supplies in insecure environments.
ACT never resorted to any militarised distribution methods – instead relying on local partners who helped secure the transfer of life-saving necessities to communities who already had their trust and support. For instance, ACT members The Christian Reformed World Relief Committee (CRWRC) and Christian Aid relied solely on local partner organisations during their distribution of critical supplies to families in the affected communities.
As the emergency phase of the response came to a close, ACT adapted its response toward rebuilding and recovery initiatives. Now, two years on, the value of the partnership approach has been demonstrated time and again in cases where local organisations have been able to guide ACT member organisations toward sustainable solutions valued – and moulded – by the local community.
CRWRC, for example, changed its home construction materials – from a tarp to plywood-based model – on the advice of members of the local Community Advisory Committee in Leogane.
“The provision of houses whose walls are clad in [a more durable, less penetrable] plywood has made families more secure, more confident in their living environment – liberating them to pursue daily activities without undue worries about the safety of their families and belongings,” explained committee member Jean Pierre Paul.
Looking ahead, partners organisations insist that international organisations must continue to reinforce their trust in and respect for local organisations – particularly now, as the international response transitions from one of humanitarian relief to long-term development. Just as grassroots initiatives were central to successful relief and recovery efforts, Haitians must continue to be at the centre of the ongoing work to build a sustainable future for their country.
Mara Caputo is the web editor for ACT Alliance.
CRWRC partner organisations who assisted with food distribution efforts in Leogone mentioned above include the Organisation des Jeunes Progressistes de Masson; Connexion des Idées Evolutives et Progressives de la Pte- Rivière de Leogane; Macombre: Regroupement des Cadres de Développement pour la Petite Rivière de Leogane; Luithor: Union des Jeunes Progressistes pour le Développement de Luithor; and Croix des Peres: Organisation des Jeunes Progressistes de Croix des Peres
- Aid community marks three years since Haiti quake
- Haiti: development must work for everyone
- No time for complacency or blame in Haiti
- Telling the full story in Haiti
- Hot lunch in Haiti: reducing hunger, enhancing learning
- Haiti: hope for the future
- Haiti: employing the partnership paradigm
- Haiti: Michicu camp
- Haiti remembers, one year on
- Haiti: Many small steps to progress
- ACT in Haiti
- Haiti: give us our land
- Haiti: Camp life
- Haiti: one year later
- Haiti: housing programme
- Haiti: health for all
- Haiti, my Haiti
- Haiti: ACT combats cholera
- Haiti: building hope through homes
- Haiti: ACT can dance!
- Haiti: Building on ACT expertise
- Haiti: Society’s “forgotten ones” get respite from hardship
- Haiti: Living in fear of sickness and death
- Hurricane Tomas leaves Léogâne in floods
- Tomas threatens half a million in Haiti
- Haiti: Tropical Storm Tomas bearing down
- School of hope
- Haiti earthquake response: six month update
- Rural Haiti: The issue is food
- Haiti: revisiting ACT projects and people
- Haiti: To praise the government or pass judgment?
- Haiti: "The first to be forgotten" reclaiming dignity
- Haiti: Six months later
- Haiti: Homeless, with an uncertain future
- Haiti: Global church leader hails ACT work
- Haiti: seeding recovery in the countryside
- Haiti: back to school
- A new Haiti – built by Haitians?
- John Nduna: “Haiti’s homeless and vulnerable deserve better”
- Haiti Prime Minister to ACT: "Elections as planned"
- Haiti camps: dignity despite misery
- Haitians help Haitians
- Haiti: “Listen to the women”
- John Nduna: ACT remains in Haiti
- Haiti earthquake: arts help children heal
- Haiti: water for the homeless
- Haiti: heavy rains underscore shelter needs
- Haiti: Indonesian children show solidarity
- Haiti earthquake: ACT Alliance at work
- Haiti: one month later
- Haiti: recent images
- Haiti: Born in the rubble